Exeter City Football Club won a penalty shootout 4-3 against Oxford United after a dramatic 2-2 draw in the EFL Trophy on Tuesday. The result secured a bonus point in the group stage, providing a morale boost for a side currently 20th in the League Two standings with nine points from nine games.

Taylor Perry gave Exeter an early lead, finishing from Liam Oakes's cross in the seventh minute. Oxford United responded just before the half-hour mark when Harrison Bradney equalised. Josh Gordon restored City's advantage almost immediately with a spectacular strike, but a Jack Fitzwater own goal with 12 minutes remaining levelled the tie again at 2-2.

The match went straight to penalties to decide the additional group point. Goalkeeper Frankie Phillips was the hero, making two key saves from Oxford's Harrison Bradney and James Golding. Exeter converted all four of their spot-kicks through Anthony Scully, Charlie Cummins, Luca Woodhouse and Louie Cayless to seal the 4-3 shootout victory. Manager Matt Taylor made several changes for the final group fixture, with captain Jack Fitzwater starting and Josh Gordon coming into the side after the warm-up.

"We showed great character to come back from 2-0 down and earn a point in a crazy finish," Taylor said. The manager's use of the squad depth was evident, and he will hope this result builds confidence. Exeter's recent form has been mixed, with a win, three draws and a loss in their last five matches across all competitions. They will look to carry this cup momentum into their league campaign, which continues this Saturday with a trip to face 14th-placed Shrewsbury Town, a key fixture in their fixtures list as they seek to improve their league position.

The club confirmed the 2-2 draw and penalty win occurred on Tuesday, 6 October 2026. Oxford United manager Aaron Ramsey highlighted his side's second-half pressure, stating, "How United didn’t win the game is beyond everyone." Exeter, 20th in League Two with nine points, face Shrewsbury Town away on Saturday, 10 October.